If your going to make this trade, def don't give up Hellickson. 

Hellickson is best player of the the 5, if you can grab him for Holland and Andino u def do it. 

I own Hellickson so both of you are saying to trade Murphy and Beckett and take on Holland and Andino?

let me break it down

murphy is a bench player for me behind cano so i am not worried about swapping him for andino

I have 6 pitchers:

Peavy, Romero, Hellickson, Beckett, Cahill and Scherzer

Is Holland going to finish stronger than Beckett? 

The only pitching categories are W(10pts) IP(2pts) K(.5pt) and ER(-1pt)

Currently Holland has 124 pts to Beckett's (107)

i think Beat mode is the best way to go but if i had to chose based on my personal preference i would ask for Ethier and Price or be ballsy and ask for Ethier and Kershaw see if he bites and how badly he wants Kemp cuz in my opinion power can be made up in batting categories as the yr goes but pitching is tricky to perdict

I think as long as you're getting Tulo you can't be too upset, a SS unlike any other.  Kershaw and Price are both awesome, but you may want to grab someone a bit more dependable than Ethier as a second part of the deal, maybe throw in one of your weaker pitchers

yeah Jeremy isnt enough either. You should ask for more than Hellickson. Tulo and Bumgardner is enough depending on your own staff

We reached an agreement and as long as Giancarlo Stanton is healthy by openinig day, I will send Matt Kemp to LABeastMode for Giancarlo and David Price

Take Jennings. If the FG doesn't hurt you then he gets more pts/assts/stls than Harden. 

Harden(14 games) leads in Pts, D Rebound, Blks and less turnovers

Jennings(12 games) has more O rebound, Steals, Assists

I think Pts will be close, but I still like Jennings long term to avg and have more. he is their go-to scorer while Harden is at best 3rd on scoring depth chart. harden will surely have less TOS, but Jennings should have more 3s. I think its very fair, I'd have no problem taking on either guy at that price 

very fair trade. Jennings should have more total pts at end of season if thats your swing category.