Trade Debate - Free Fantasy Sports Community

MoreThanFantasy
In a 10 team Non-Keeper PPR Head-to-Head league hosted by YAHOO! Sports, which manager gets the better fantasy trade?
Posted by MoreThanFantasy on October 16, 2012
Post the first comment

Tweet

Email
Loading...
Manager A

Gronkowski, Rob(Patriots - TE)

Lynch, Marshawn(Seahawks - RB)

Smith, Steve(Panthers - WR)

....

Manager A
Fair
Manager B

Graham, Jimmy(Saints - TE)

Welker, Wes(Patriots - PR/WR/KR)

Mathews, Ryan(Chargers - RB)

....

Manager B
Voting on this trade has closed: Post a Comment
21.05% for Manager A (4 votes) 21.05% Fair (4 votes) 57.89% for Manager B (11 votes)
MoreThanFantasy
In a 10 team Non-Keeper PPR Head-to-Head Standard Scoring league hosted by YAHOO! Sports, which manager gets the better fantasy trade?
Posted by MoreThanFantasy on October 15, 2012
Post the first comment

Tweet

Email
Loading...
Manager A

Mathews, Ryan(Chargers - RB)

Manager A
Fair
Manager B

Marshall, Brandon(Bears - WR)

Green, Alex(Packers - RB)

Manager B
Voting on this trade has closed: Post a Comment
45.24% for Manager A (19 votes) 11.9% Fair (5 votes) 42.86% for Manager B (18 votes)
MoreThanFantasy
In a 10 team Non-Keeper Head-to-Head Custom Scoring league hosted by YAHOO! Sports, which manager gets the better fantasy trade?
Posted by MoreThanFantasy on September 12, 2012
Show 2 comments | View Manager's notes

This is a PPR league with 2 flex positions. I am stacked at WR with Marshall, Cruz, White and Bowe. My RB's are Stewart, McCluster Gerhart, Jennings, Mendenhall and Turbin. I have only 1 starter right now other than Stewart if he returns this week. I know I'm losing out on the deal normally, but in this situation what do you guys think?

Tweet

Email
Loading...
I Give (Read Notes!)

Stewart, Jonathan(Panthers - RB)

Marshall, Brandon(Bears - WR)

I Give (Read Notes!)
Fair
I Get (Read Notes!)

Charles, Jamaal(Chiefs - RB)

Bush, Michael(Bears - RB)

I Get (Read Notes!)
Voting on this trade has closed: Post a Comment
38.64% for I Give (Read Notes!) (17 votes) 22.73% Fair (10 votes) 38.64% for I Get (Read Notes!) (17 votes)
MoreThanFantasy

MoreThanFantasy 252 days ago
12 team not 10 team

Mongo

Mongo 251 days ago
considering your situation it's fair. You can even make a case that your getting the better end of the deal.
MoreThanFantasy
In a 10 team Non-Keeper Head-to-Head Custom Scoring league hosted by YAHOO! Sports, which manager gets the better fantasy trade?
Posted by MoreThanFantasy on August 31, 2012
Post the first comment

Tweet

Email
Loading...
Manager A

Johnson, Chris(Titans - RB)

Moore, Lance(Saints - WR)

Manager A
Fair
Manager B

Britt, Kenny(Titans - WR)

Johnson, Stevie(Bills - WR)

Manager B
Voting on this trade has closed: Post a Comment
82.14% for Manager A (23 votes) 7.14% Fair (2 votes) 10.71% for Manager B (3 votes)
MoreThanFantasy
In a 10 team Keeper Head-to-Head Categories (5X5) league hosted by YAHOO! Sports, which manager gets the better fantasy trade?
Posted by MoreThanFantasy on June 20, 2012
Show 4 comments | View Manager's notes

In this keeper league, you get a budget of $100 to keep players. Pujols went for $48 and Bruce for $29. Trout went for $9, Heyward for $11 and Hosmer for $19. The objective is to keep as many undervalued players as possible. Team B leads the league in HR and RBI.

Tweet

Email
Loading...
Manager A

Trout, Mike(Angels - CF/LF/RF)

Heyward, Jason(Braves - RF/CF)

Hosmer, Eric(Royals - 1B/RF)

....

Manager A
Fair
Manager B

Pujols, Albert(Angels - 1B/3B)

Bruce, Jay(Reds - RF/CF)

Manager B
Voting on this trade has closed: Post a Comment
68.75% for Manager A (11 votes) 25% Fair (4 votes) 6.25% for Manager B (1 votes)
Tigress

Tigress 337 days ago
Trout for $9 alone is enough for me to make that Trade. Great deal for A at some great prices.

Chad P. Martin

Chad P. Martin 337 days ago
It's fair, but I'd rather have A. Ton's of potential at a fraction of the price.

Rod Belding

Rod Belding 337 days ago
I dont think team B leading the league ion RBI/HR is impt to the deal, but rather how A can build in the future, and I think this gives him a great base.

MoreThanFantasy

MoreThanFantasy 337 days ago
I worded that wrong - Team A in this case is leading in HR/RBI. The team getting the young studs loses out in HR/RBI but I believe wins in long term value. I have Pujols and Bruce now, looking to get some solid keepers. I don't think the manager is going to do it though.

1.

2.

3.

4.

5.

6.

7.

8.

9.

10.

1.

2.

3.

4.

5.

6.

7.

8.

9.

10.

1.

2.

3.

4.

5.

6.

7.

8.

9.

10.

1.

2.

3.

4.

5.

6.

7.

8.

9.

10.

Latest tweets