Trade Debate - Free Fantasy Sports Community

Arthuro
In a 10 team Keeper Head-to-Head Custom Categories league hosted by YAHOO! Sports, which manager gets the better fantasy trade?
Posted by Arthuro on March 20, 2013
Post the first comment | View Manager's notes
Prospects could be added to either side of the trade. Let me know if you feel they should be, or if it is relatively fair as is.

Custom Categories:
Batting Average (AVG)
Hits (H)
Home Runs (HR)
On Base Pct (OBP)
Runs Batted In (RBI)
Runs Scored (R)
Slugging Pct (SLG)
Stolen Bases (SB)
Strikeouts (KO)
W
Batting Average (AVG)
Hits (H)
Home Runs (HR)
On Base Pct (OBP)
Runs Batted In (RBI)
Runs Scored (R)
Slugging Pct (SLG)
Stolen Bases (SB)
Strikeouts (KO)
W
Tweet

Email
Loading...
Manager A

Gonzalez, Carlos(Rockies - LF/CF)

Greinke, Zack(Dodgers - SP)

Manager A
Fair
Manager B

Braun, Ryan(Brewers - LF)

Lynn, Lance(Cardinals - SP)

Manager B
Voting on this trade has closed: Post a Comment
54.55% for Manager A (36 votes) 18.18% Fair (12 votes) 27.27% for Manager B (18 votes)
dglass1
In a 8 team Keeper Head-to-Head Points league hosted by ESPN Fantasy and Games, which manager gets the better fantasy trade?
Posted by dglass1 on March 20, 2013
Post the first comment | View Manager's notes

Would it be more fair if if Team B did not receive the 14 round pick.

Tweet

Email
Loading...
1 round pick 8, 2:1, 12:1

, ( - )

1 round pick 8, 2:1,...
Fair
1 round pick 3, 4:6, 5:3, 14:6

, ( - )

1 round pick 3, 4:6,...
Voting on this trade has closed: Post a Comment
37.93% for 1 round pick 8, 2:1, 12:1 (11 votes) 27.59% Fair (8 votes) 34.48% for 1 round pick 3, 4:6, 5:3, 14:6 (10 votes)
MikeSmith35
In a 10 team Keeper Head-to-Head Categories (5X5) league hosted by CBS Sports, which manager gets the better fantasy trade?
Posted by MikeSmith35 on March 20, 2013
Post the first comment

Tweet

Email
Loading...
10th Round Keeper

Desmond, Ian(Nationals - SS)

10th Round Keeper
Fair
10th Round Keeper

Sale, Chris(White Sox - SP)

10th Round Keeper
Voting on this trade has closed: Post a Comment
20.41% for 10th Round Keeper (10 votes) 18.37% Fair (9 votes) 61.22% for 10th Round Keeper (30 votes)
dglass1
In a 8 team Keeper Head-to-Head Custom Scoring league hosted by ESPN Fantasy and Games, which manager gets the better fantasy trade?
Posted by dglass1 on March 19, 2013
Post the first comment

Tweet

Email
Loading...
2 round pick 1, 4:1, 6:1

, ( - )

2 round pick 1, 4:1,...
Fair
1:3, 18:6

, ( - )

1:3, 18:6
Voting on this trade has closed: Post a Comment
40.74% for 2 round pick 1, 4:1, 6:1 (11 votes) 18.52% Fair (5 votes) 40.74% for 1:3, 18:6 (11 votes)
M.Moose
In a 14 team Dynasty Head-to-Head Points league hosted by CBS Sports, which manager gets the better fantasy trade?
Posted by M.Moose on March 18, 2013
Post the first comment

Tweet

Email
Loading...
Manager A

Zobrist, Ben(Rays - RF/2B/SS)

Norris, Bud(Astros - SP/RP)

Manager A
Fair
Manager B

Harvey, Matt(Mets - SP)

Lowrie, Jed(Athletics - SS/3B)

Manager B
Voting on this trade has closed: Post a Comment
31.15% for Manager A (19 votes) 27.87% Fair (17 votes) 40.98% for Manager B (25 votes)
Jeff Heiser Jr
In a 14 team Dynasty Head-to-Head Categories (5X5) league hosted by ESPN Fantasy and Games, which manager gets the better fantasy trade?
Posted by Jeff Heiser Jr on March 18, 2013
Post the first comment

Tweet

Email
Loading...
Manager A

Upton, Justin(Braves - RF/LF)

Manager A
Fair
Manager B

Gonzalez, Carlos(Rockies - LF/CF)

Manager B
Voting on this trade has closed: Post a Comment
15.15% for Manager A (10 votes) 21.21% Fair (14 votes) 63.64% for Manager B (42 votes)
notoriousjim
In a 12 team Dynasty Head-to-Head Categories (5X5) league hosted by YAHOO! Sports, which manager gets the better fantasy trade?
Posted by notoriousjim on March 18, 2013
Show 1 comments | View Manager's notes

full team keeper, the team trading away braun is rebuilding (he just took over the team, and even though it was a playoff team last year he has chosen to blow it up)

Tweet

Email
Loading...
Manager A

Braun, Ryan(Brewers - LF)

Manager A
Fair
Manager B

Kimbrel, Craig(Braves - RP/CL)

Darvish, Yu(Rangers - SP)

Frieri, Ernesto(Angels - RP)

....

Manager B
Voting on this trade has closed: Post a Comment
66.18% for Manager A (45 votes) 10.29% Fair (7 votes) 23.53% for Manager B (16 votes)
Mongo

Mongo 64 days ago
That makes no sense, why blow up a playoff team?
MikeSmith35
In a 10 team Keeper Head-to-Head Categories (5X5) league hosted by CBS Sports, which manager gets the better fantasy trade?
Posted by MikeSmith35 on March 18, 2013
Post the first comment | View Manager's notes

Which is the Better Keeper?

Tweet

Email
Loading...
10th Round Keeper

Sale, Chris(White Sox - SP)

10th Round Keeper
Fair
18th Round Keeper

Morrow, Brandon(Blue Jays - SP)

18th Round Keeper
Voting on this trade has closed: Post a Comment
80% for 10th Round Keeper (44 votes) 5.45% Fair (3 votes) 14.55% for 18th Round Keeper (8 votes)
ashtray
In a 12 team Dynasty Head-to-Head Custom Categories league hosted by Optional, which manager gets the better fantasy trade?
Posted by ashtray on March 17, 2013
Post the first comment | View Manager's notes
Team A has very strong pitching (Verlander, Waino, Sale, Harvey, Medlen, Garza), Team B pitching is thin beyond Strasburg, Zimm, CJ Wilson, A Sanchez. Deal also involves a Team A receiving a prospect (1 of Jackie Bradley, Alen Hanson, Boegarts, Sano, Correa, Russell, Dahl).

Custom Categories:
Batting Average (AVG)
Hits (H)
Home Runs (HR)
On Base plus Slugging Pct (OPS)
Runs Batted In (RBI)
Runs Scored (R)
Stolen Bases (SB)
Strikeouts (KO)
Total
Batting Average (AVG)
Hits (H)
Home Runs (HR)
On Base plus Slugging Pct (OPS)
Runs Batted In (RBI)
Runs Scored (R)
Stolen Bases (SB)
Strikeouts (KO)
Total
Tweet

Email
Loading...
Team A (also receives a prospect)

Rutledge, Josh(Rockies - SS/2B)

Upton, B.J.(Braves - CF)

Zimmermann, Jordan(Nationals - SP)

....

Team A (also receive...
Fair
Team B

Middlebrooks, Will(Red Sox - 3B)

Medlen, Kris(Braves - SP/RP)

Garza, Matt(Cubs - SP)

Gose, Anthony(Blue Jays - RF/CF/LF)

....

Team B
Voting on this trade has closed: Post a Comment
75% for Team A (also receives a prospect) (33 votes) 20.45% Fair (9 votes) 4.55% for Team B (2 votes)
M.Moose
In a 16 team Dynasty Head-to-Head Points league hosted by CBS Sports, which manager gets the better fantasy trade?
Posted by M.Moose on March 16, 2013
Post the first comment | View Manager's notes

Can't find prospects in the player list. Used players to be traded as names of teams.

Tweet

Email
Loading...
P. Bourjos and Cingrani

, ( - )

P. Bourjos and Cingr...
Fair
Gausman

, ( - )

Gausman
Voting on this trade has closed: Post a Comment
60% for P. Bourjos and Cingrani (27 votes) 22.22% Fair (10 votes) 17.78% for Gausman (8 votes)

1.

2.

3.

4.

5.

6.

7.

8.

9.

10.

1.

2.

3.

4.

5.

6.

7.

8.

9.

10.

1.

2.

3.

4.

5.

6.

7.

1.

2.

3.

4.

5.

6.

7.

8.

9.

10.

Latest tweets